12 August 2012

Half-Term Report 2012

With eleven races down and nine still to go, it’s time for my annual ‘half-term report’. Who is the teacher’s pet, and who deserves the dunce’s cap?

Fernando Alonso (E, Ferrari), 1st, 164 pts, 3 wins                               A+
Simply put, Fernando Alonso has so far this year been the class of the field. Few would have been brave enough to put a bet on a resurgence of this magnitude by the half-way mark of the season considering how uncompetitive the Ferrari appeared in Melbourne, but some relentless development by the team combined with some peerless driving from Alonso has given the Spaniard a healthy 40-point buffer heading into the summer break. Part of his genius stems from an uncanny knack of maximising his points haul at every event – Hungary is a case in point, as Alonso banked a fifth place finish and ten points despite the Ferrari showing less raw pace than the Red Bull, Lotus and McLaren. In a season like 2012, it will be those weekends rather than those when the Ferrari is capable of winning that will make him an extremely hard man to beat before the season is out.

Lewis Hamilton (GB, McLaren), 4th, 117 pts, 2 wins                          A
It was clear almost from the outset of this season that Lewis Hamilton had well and truly put behind him what can only be described as an annus horribilis of a 2011 campaign. The win-or-bust attitude that saw him languish behind Jenson Button in last year’s standings was replaced by a new brand of tamed aggression that saw him lead the way after three rounds after racking up three consecutive third places. Blunders by his McLaren team unfortunately served to cost him dearly at Bahrain and Spain, particularly as a win seemed on the cards at the latter. That first trip to the top step of the podium finally arrived at Canada, where Hamilton executed the winning strategy to perfection, whilst his equally briliant win at Hungary was sorely-needed to re-invigorate his title hopes after a somewhat fallow period during the previous three races. He may have a gap of almost 50 points to close, but if McLaren can deliver then Hamilton is far from out of the running.

Sebastian Vettel (D, Red Bull), 3rd, 122 pts, 1 win                              A
It’s been anything but a straightforward title defence for the man that took last year’s title with such consummate ease, but Sebastian Vettel has for the most part had the measure of teammate Mark Webber in pure speed terms and has extracted the most from his machinery so far. He’s taken three pole positions so far this year, and his tally of two podiums belies his pace at certain events this year. His victory at Bahrain was textbook stuff, and prior to the alternator failure that brought his Red Bull to a halt in Valencia he was escaping from the field at a fearsome rate. A strategic miscue during the closing stages at Canada also denied him a potential runner-up position, and without those two mishaps he would be within nine points of Alonso’s championship lead. There have been occasions where Webber has had the better of him, Silverstone being chief among them, but when push comes to shove Vettel has to be considered the better title bet of the two Red Bull contenders.

Kimi Raikkonen (FIN, Lotus), 5th, 116 pts, 0 wins                                                A-
Although doubts naturally surfaced whether Kimi Raikkonen would be able to cut it at the sharp end of the field after two seasons away in the WRC, the phlegmatic Finn has proved he has lost none of his lustre and has marked himself out as one of the most consistent performers of the season. He’s had more podium finishes than everybody bar Alonso and Hamilton, and whilst none of those visits have been to the top step, his performances at Bahrain and Hungary in particular mean it would take a brave person to bet against him clinching a victory before the season is out. Though qualifying has sometimes been suspect, having been outqualified by Lotus stablemate Romain Grosjean more often than not, Raikkonen has still scored points at every round bar China – it’s been this consistency that has allowed him to stave off the challenge of his rapid teammate and go into the final nine races with an outside shot of title glory.

Mark Webber (AU, Red Bull), 2nd, 124 pts, 2 wins                             A-
After a bitterly disappointing 2011, this season was widely viewed as the last chance for Mark Webber to fight for the title he so narrowly missed out on two years ago. The year started in unspectacular fashion as the down-to-earth Aussie racked up a quartet of fourth place finishes, and since then his form has varied alarmingly – after a difficult weekend in Spain that failed to yield any points, he underlined his title credentials in Monaco with an excellent victory from pole position. After two more races at Canada and Valencia where he was overshadowed by teammate Vettel, he had the measure of the German all weekend at Silverstone and executed his tyre strategy to perfection to take a popular victory ahead of Alonso. Webber has only banked two more eighth places since then, so his title chances would appear to hinge on how consistently he can perform in the remaining nine races of the year.

Romain Grosjean (F, Lotus), 8th, 76 pts, 0 wins                                   B+
Following two seasons in the wilderness after a lacklustre F1 debut in 2009, Romain Grosjean immediately made his presence felt in the first race of the season at Melbourne by qualifying third. That set the tone for what has been a highly impressive campaign thus far at least as far as raw pace is concerned, although there has inevitably been the odd mistake given his inexperience – first lap exits at Malaysia and Monaco that were of his own doing as well as an error-strewn race at Hockenheim are the most noticeable blots on his copybook.  On the other hand, three visits to the podium, which would have been four without that alternator failure at Valencia, can certainly be regarded as a job well done for the Franco-Swiss, his level-headed drive to second place at Montreal standing out in particular. As his experience grows, we should begin to see fewer errors and more maturity to go with his eye-catching pace.

Sergio Perez (MEX, Sauber), 9th, 47 pts, 0 wins                                   B+
If Sergio Perez’s achievements in his rookie season were arguably overlooked, in the UK at least, as a result of fellow newcomer Paul Di Resta’s successes, this year’s second race at Malaysia made the whole world stand up and take notice of the Mexican. In torrential conditions, Perez came within one tiny mistake of overhauling Alonso to take his and his Sauber team’s (as an independent constructor) first victory in the sport. Since then, Perez has continued to rack up the points, despite experiencing his fair share of bad luck – particularly at Spain and Monaco. His drive to third at Canada underlined his flair for tyre preservation, and a couple more similar performances before the year is out will give Perez a good shot at what would be a deserved promotion to Ferrari next year.

Nico Rosberg (D, Mercedes), 6th, 77 pts, 1 win                                   B
Having been somewhat overshadowed by Mercedes teammate Michael Schumacher towards the end of last year, the onus coming into 2012 was firmly on Nico Rosberg to re-gain the upper hand. He did so with his overdue but perfectly executed maiden win in China, where he made the best possible use of his machinery being ideally suited to the circumstances. It’s been a mixed bag for Rosberg since then, largely owing to how inconsistently the Mercedes car has performed. The German has delivered when it has been competitive, as was the case during his textbook run to second at Monaco, but on the same token has looked rather ordinary when the car has proven a handful, as was the case at both Silverstone and Hockenheim where Schumacher was still able to salvage decent points. The last few races have put paid to any outside hope of a championship tilt, but Rosberg will nonetheless be keen to re-capture the imperious form that took him to what he’ll be hoping won’t be his last F1 victory.

Michael Schumacher (D, Mercedes), 12th, 29 pts, 0 wins                               B
Perhaps the unluckiest man in the sport this season, the 48-point gap that separates Michael Schumacher from teammate Rosberg fails to reflect what has been the most convincing season of the seven time champion’s F1 comeback so far. Things started on a sour note as gearbox trouble eliminated Schumacher from third place in Melbourne before a botched pit-stop cost him what seemed a comfortable second place behind Rosberg in China. In addition, DRS issues in qualifying at Bahrain and the race at Canada as well as a fuel pressure problem in Monaco have all cost Schumacher valuable points. There have been mistakes, most notable his collision with Bruno Senna in Spain and his calamitous weekend at Hungary, but he has given Rosberg as hard a time as he’s ever done during their years as teammates. At the ripe old age of 43, as that fastest qualifying lap at Monaco attests, he’s still capable of mixing it with the best of them.

Kamui Kobayashi (J, Sauber), 10th, 33 pts, 0 wins                               B-
Moving into his third full season of F1, Kamui Kobayashi is arguably yet to capitalise on the amazing potential he displayed during those two races in which he drove for Toyota at the end of 2009. At certain races, principally in Spain and Germany, he has driven superbly and has looked just about as convincing as any of the other up-and-coming drivers in the field. On the other hand, he has been more error prone than his less experienced teammate Perez, his Silverstone pit-lane incident standing out as his most costly blunder, and has on occasions inexplicably had no answer to his fellow Sauber driver’s prodigious race pace. Kobayashi’s lack of funding means he has to demonstrate he deserves what could this winter transpire to be a hotly-contested Sauber seat on merit alone. Cutting out the errors and replicating his good weekends on a more frequent basis will be the key to doing that.

Pastor Maldonado (YV, Williams), 11th, 29 pts, 1 win                      B-
The first race of the year in Melbourne, where a last lap crash marred what would otherwise have been a superb drive to sixth place, very much set the tone for Pastor Maldonado’s season so far. When he took his Williams team’s first victory in eight years at Barcelona in emphatic fashion, he was predictably being touted as the sport’s next big thing. Just two weeks later in Monaco, he became the sport’s pantomine villain as he deliberately swerved into Perez during free practice, costing himself a top ten grid slot on his favourite circuit. He was on course for a podium finish before he was too aggressive in trying to pass Lewis Hamilton during the closing stages at Valencia, whilst a solid points finish went west at Silverstone as he again clashed with Perez during the race. The talent is clearly there, it’s a simple matter of applying it in a less hot-headed manner for the Venezuelan in order to fulfil his potential.

Jenson Button (GB, McLaren), 7th, 76 pts, 1 win                                 C+
After beating Vettel and Hamilton to the chequered flag at Melbourne, Jenson Button appeared to have continued where he had left off last year. Unfortunately for the Brit however,  this result proved to be something of a false dawn. After netting a second podium finish at China, things went downhill very quickly: after losing a sixth place finish to a differential failure at Bahrain, his inability to switch on the tyres, paradoxically thus causing them to wear faster, led to a spell in the doldrums. He didn’t truly get back on top of things until Germany, where he showed winning pace for the first time since China en route to second, but the fatal damage to his title challenge has been done. Hamilton has firmly established his superiority over Button since those opening races, clearly evidenced by a qualifying record of 10-1 in favour of the former, meaning Button owes it to his team to start supporting Lewis’s title bid.

Bruno Senna (BR, Williams), 15th, 24 pts, 0 wins                                                C-
Where teammate Maldonado has been lightning quick but prone to the odd on-track clash, Senna has been the dependable, steady points gatherer for the Williams team. Whilst adopting such a role is not a bad thing in and of itself, the problem is that nagging feeling that there’s so much more to be unlocked from the Williams car than Senna is currently able to extract. His qualifying record has been lacklustre, and his race pace has often found wanting in comparison to that of his teammate – although he has shown solid pace on some occasions, not least in Hungary, sixth and two seventh places don’t look quite as good stacked up against a victory for Maldonado. With Valtteri Bottas waiting patiently in the wings to replace Senna, the Brazilian needs to prove in the second half of the year that he’s a match for his quick-but-erratic teammate.

Felipe Massa (BR, Ferrari), 14th, 25 pts, 0 wins                                    D
Ever since that fateful afternoon in Hungary three years ago, Felipe Massa has been on a steady downward trajectory. In 2010, after 11 races, the gap between the Brazilian and his teammate Fernando Alonso was 38 points; at the same point in 2011 it was 75; this year it currently stands at 139. Each season has been a bigger disappointment than the last, and the prospect of Massa ever returning to his sparkling form of 2008 is as slim as ever. Top six finishes at Monaco and Silverstone may have been the highlights of his year so far, but on neither occasion did he truly threaten Alonso. Notwithstanding a spectacular resurgence in the second half of the year, he is virtually certain to lose his Ferrari seat – on the basis that he is on the record as being unwilling to drive for anything besides a top team, this could well be Massa’s final season in F1.

The Rest
Neither Force India driver has given the impression of vastly outperforming the car so far this year, with Nico Hulkenberg (C+) recently beginning to outshine teammate Paul di Resta (B-) after something of a slow start. The Scot has been a consistent if unspectacular performer up to now, but needs to up his game somewhat in order to keep Hulkenberg at bay and keep up the momentum in his career. The Toro Rosso teammates Daniel Ricciardo (C) and Jean-Eric Vergne (C-) have been difficult to assess given how far away the car’s performance has fallen from the rest of the midfield pack, but it has been the Australian who has finished ahead of the Frenchman more often than not despite his smaller points tally. Heikki Kovalainen (A) has been as excellent as ever, and deserves far better than the lot he has at Caterham, whilst Vitaly Petrov (B) has been closer to the Finn’s pace than many had predicted. Timo Glock (B+) likewise has done little wrong at the wheel of the woeful Marussia, with Charles Pic (B) seemingly improving by the race at the wheel of the other car. Pedro de la Rosa (B) meanwhile seems to have helped to bring his HRT squad closer to their Marussia rivals, even if he does languish at the very bottom of the drivers’ standings, whilst it’s fair to say that Narain Karthikeyan (C) is probably exceeding the (admittedly rather modest) expectations of most F1 viewers.

No comments:

Post a Comment